InfoSAWIT, JAKARTA — The Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court (MKMK) has formally issued a verbal reprimand to nine Constitutional Court justices following an ethics review related to a fundamental error in Constitutional Court Decision No. 147/PUU-XXII/2024. The ethics verdict was read on 17 November 2025.
The complaint was filed by Muhamad Zainal Arifin, Director of the Center for Legal Studies and Advocacy on Natural Resources (PUSTAKA ALAM), together with Simons Manurung. They highlighted a critical mistake in paragraph 3.13.3 on page 255 of the ruling issued on 16 October 2025, where the Court stated that forest areas are regions “designated and/or determined by the Government.”
This wording contradicts Constitutional Court Decision No. 45/PUU-IX/2011, which nullified the term “designated.”
“This is not a typo. It is a serious legal error because it revives a norm that has been declared unconstitutional,” Zainal said in a statement received by InfoSAWIT.
MKMK: The Error Is Substantive, Not Editorial
The MKMK panel — I Dewa Gede Palguna (Chair), Ridwan Mansyur, and Yuliandri — found that the justices violated the principles of competence and prudence mandated by the Court’s code of ethics. They emphasized that the ruling should have relied solely on the term “determined,” in line with the amended definition under Law No. 6/2023.
MKMK also stressed collective responsibility: Constitutional Court rulings are produced through a nine-justice deliberation system, implying multiple layers of review should have prevented the error.
Court Issues Renvoi, Admits Error
The Constitutional Court issued a Renvoi Minutes on 27 October 2025, officially removing the erroneous phrase and notifying all relevant parties, including the President and DPR. Zainal welcomed the correction and said the report aimed to safeguard the Court’s integrity, not embarrass the justices.
Legal Implications: Designation No Longer Sufficient
Zainal stated that the ruling reaffirms that forest area designation alone carries no legal force unless followed by formal boundary demarcation and determination.
“Stop using designation decrees as the basis for forest claims. Designation has no legal effect,” he stressed.
The MKMK’s decision underscores the Court’s crucial role as guardian of constitutional norms, highlighting how a seemingly small editorial error may affect millions of hectares of land and the rights of communities within them. (T2)







