InfoSAWIT, PETALING JAYA — The European Union's decision to classify Malaysia under the "standard risk" category in its new European Union Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) has drawn sharp criticism from stakeholders in the Malaysian palm oil industry. This classification is feared to create significant non-tariff barriers that could severely impact the sustainability of Malaysia's palm oil exports to the European market.
Datuk Carl Bek-Nielsen, Chairman of the Malaysian Palm Oil Council (MPOC), described the classification as "very unfair and disappointing." He argued that the assessment overlooks Malaysia's significant progress in reducing deforestation rates and implementing high sustainability standards in the palm oil sector.
“It feels like being penalized for speeding when we are actually driving below the speed limit. It’s incredibly unjust. This is a slap in the face for an industry that has worked hard, and for the first time in over 100 years, our palm oil plantation area is actually decreasing,” he stated, as reported by InfoSAWIT from The Star on Tuesday (July 8, 2025).
Bek-Nielsen warned that being classified as "standard risk" or even "high risk" would carry severe consequences. Countries with such statuses will face stricter compliance obligations and greater administrative burdens to access the EU market.
“They will incur significantly higher compliance costs due to the stringent EUDR regulations and will be subject to more intense scrutiny by competent authorities in Europe,” he explained.
According to the European Commission, the EUDR risk classification is based on levels of deforestation, forest degradation, agricultural land expansion, and trends in related commodity production. However, Bek-Nielsen contended that this assessment does not reflect the reality on the ground, particularly Malaysia's long-term commitment to sustainable land management.
Serious Threat to Small Farmers
A similar sentiment was echoed by Roslin Azmy Hassan, CEO of the Malaysian Palm Oil Association (MPOA). He noted that the EUDR could become a non-tariff trade barrier detrimental to commodity-producing countries in the Global South, especially small farmers in Malaysia.
“For Malaysia, this could mean that palm oil farmers, particularly smallholders, are pushed out of the EU market, even though they have adhered to national sustainability standards like the Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO),” Roslin stated.
He emphasized that sanctions imposed without considering sustainability efforts threaten farmers' livelihoods and hinder broader economic development goals. There are also concerns that importers and processors in Europe may avoid Malaysia in favor of countries classified as "low risk" to sidestep complex compliance processes.
Roslin further asserted that this risk classification does not reflect Malaysia's genuine commitment to forest protection. He reminded that since the 1992 Rio Earth Summit, Malaysia has committed to maintaining at least 50% of its territory as forested land—and this promise remains upheld.
He also questioned the integrity of the EUDR classification system, noting that some EU member states with historical deforestation records are categorized as "low risk."
“This discrepancy raises serious questions about the objectivity and transparency of the EUDR framework. It seems biased and reinforces the impression that the EUDR is being used as a discriminatory tool against palm oil,” he asserted.
Despite Malaysia's active participation in various consultative forums, including the Joint Task Force with the EU, Roslin admitted that the outcomes have been negligible. Many of these dialogues, he said, have turned into mere symbolic events without tangible policy follow-ups.
“Frequently, these discussions become ceremonial, lacking concrete results or genuine collaboration. This raises serious questions about the integrity of the EUDR consultative process. This regulation is not just a technical error; it reflects a discriminatory trade policy targeting palm oil while turning a blind eye to similar issues in other regions,” Roslin stated.
On the other hand, Malaysia's Deputy Minister of Plantation and Commodities, Datuk Chan Foong Hin, announced that the government would seek official clarification from the European Commission regarding the assessment methodology used in determining the risk classification. This step is taken as an official objection and a diplomatic effort to advocate for justice for the Malaysian palm oil industry amid increasingly complex global trade regulations. (T2)







