InfoSAWIT, JAKARTA – Several civil society organizations united in the Coalition for Clean Transition have strongly condemned the bribery scandal involving the export permits for crude palm oil (CPO), which implicates the Chief Judge of South Jakarta and three other judges. This scandal highlights the fragility of judicial integrity and deepens the governance crisis within Indonesia's palm oil industry.
The bribery case, amounting to IDR 60 billion, aimed to exonerate palm oil corporations from legal repercussions and is seen as a serious setback in the reform efforts for the palm oil sector. Greenpeace Indonesia Forest Campaigner Refki Saputra views this case as evidence of systematic practices by large corporations to evade legal accountability, while also shedding light on the weak bureaucratic reforms in land use and permitting.
“The acquittal decision has significant loopholes. The source of the IDR 60 billion bribe must be thoroughly investigated. Is it solely from one company?” Refki stated during a media briefing monitored by InfoSAWIT on Monday (April 28, 2025).
Refki also criticized the government's tendency to take shortcuts, such as transferring palm oil plantations in forest areas to state-owned enterprises, without addressing the root issues of governance.
From within the companies, palm oil practitioner Mansuetus Darto revealed that data manipulation, the use of fictitious companies, and bribery of stakeholders remain rampant, despite corporations like Wilmar and Musim Mas having anti-corruption and sustainability commitments.
“That commitment is merely on paper. In reality, corruption persists. There is something fundamentally wrong with its implementation,” Darto remarked.
Meanwhile, Satya Bumi Campaign Manager Sayyidaatihayaa Afra emphasized that the No-Deforestation, No Peat, No Exploitation (NDPE) commitment often touted as a slogan is, in fact, hollow. She highlighted the weak responses from certification initiatives like RSPO, ISPO, and the EUDR mechanism in addressing this case.
“This corruption sabotages every effort towards sustainable environmental governance. If they are serious, their certifications should be revoked,” Hayaa asserted.
This case also serves as a stark signal for the judiciary. According to STH Jentera academic Grahat Nagara, the scandal reveals the persistent influence of judicial mafia even at the Supreme Court level, while internal oversight mechanisms like the Judicial Commission are deemed ineffective.
“This incident embarrasses our legal institutions. There have been too many corruption cases in the judiciary, yet the Supreme Court's response has been very weak,” Grahat emphasized.
The coalition demands comprehensive reforms in the judiciary and natural resource governance, noting that this case is not just about individual corruption but reflects systemic failures in upholding justice and sustainability in Indonesia. (T2)







